Serving as an unpaid caregiver for a loved one is often described as a labor of love. However, as many American women in the workforce can attest, it is also incredibly demanding labor.
This dual role as both a dedicated employee and a primary caregiver is effectively the same as working two full-time jobs. We are taking another look at an insightful article from The Hill that explores this growing pressure on women. While the original reporting is a few years old, the core issues remain highly relevant today. Reporter Kirstie McDermott examined data that highlights the disproportionate burden caregiving places on women, even as female workforce participation reaches record levels.
We’ll look into McDermott’s article to understand why planning ahead is vital. For most families, it is increasingly likely that a family member will require regular care sooner or later. When that happens, you may be the one called upon to provide it.
Record Levels of Women in the U.S. Labor Force
McDermott begins her analysis by highlighting a significant shift in the American economy. She shares a startling statistic regarding the number of women currently holding paid positions: “There are almost two million more women aged 24 to 54 in the U.S. labor force than there were five years ago, hitting an all-time high in May of [2024].”
This surge is largely a byproduct of the changes brought about by the COVID-19 pandemic. McDermott notes that as working styles became less rigid through remote and hybrid options, new professional possibilities unlocked for women.
Understanding the Risks of Unemployment for Women
Despite these gains, women in the workforce still face significant vulnerabilities. Data from the World Economic Forum (WEF) indicates that the professional landscape remains uneven.
“Historically, women have consistently faced higher unemployment rates than men, except for a short period in 2020,” says the WEF report. “Since then, the likelihood of women experiencing unemployment is again higher than for men.”
McDermott further explains that women are more susceptible to being out of work entirely. The global female jobs gap rate of 15 percent sits significantly higher than the 10.5 percent rate seen among men.
Why Caregiving Responsibilities Limit Job Mobility
Finding and maintaining a career is often more difficult for women because of their availability. The WEF reports that women are much less likely to be able to start a new role on short notice. The organization states, “Evidence suggests that these gaps persist due to both a lack of suitable job opportunities and lack of access to existing opportunities, in turn due to disproportionate care responsibilities and discouragement to search for opportunities, among other factors.”
When women do find work under these constraints, the WEF notes they often end up in positions with substandard conditions. This is a direct result of having fewer choices due to their responsibilities at home.
The Growing Weight of Elder Care on Female Workers
The disparity in the workforce is often rooted in the heavy weight of caregiving. Our aging population is a major factor in why this burden continues to grow.
McDermott writes, “In 2022, there were 58 million people aged 65 and older [according to the Population Reference Bureau], and this is projected to increase by 47 percent to 2050.”
A report from Wells Fargo confirms that the biggest burden of elder care falls on women. They accounted for 59 percent of unpaid caregiving in 2021–2022, with women aged 55 and older making up 30 percent of that group.
“Women shoulder a disproportionate share of these care responsibilities, and with them a disproportionate share of the costs,” the report says. It adds that women are leaned on for both unpaid and paid care roles.
Balancing Child Care and Professional Expectations
The challenges of caregiving are not limited to elder care alone. Women remain significantly more involved in child care, which creates further friction with their professional lives.
McDermott cites a report finding that 46 percent of mothers left the workforce in 2021 due to child care issues. Other data indicates that men spend only 76 percent of the time caregiving that women do.
When you combine this reality with the record number of women in the labor force, the conclusion is undeniable. Many women are essentially working two jobs, though one of them is almost certainly unpaid.
How Resumé Gaps Impact Long-Term Career Success
These dual responsibilities often lead to “resumé gaps.” These gaps can cause women to be overlooked during the job application process, compounding their financial disadvantage.
Between the gender pay gap and the cultural pressure of choosing between children and a career, many are changing their approach to family life.
McDermott notes that an increasing share of Americans are opting out of parenthood. She writes, “Recent Pew Research Centre data identified that the U.S. fertility rate reached a historic low last year.” Pew’s research found that the number of people who say they are unlikely to ever have children increased by 10 percentage points between 2018 and 2023. This reflects a major shift in how people view the “two-job trap.”
The Economic Potential of Supporting Working Caregivers
McDermott argues that more must be done to free women from this trap. Beyond the personal benefits, there are clear economic advantages to better supporting caregivers.
“The Gates Foundation has identified that providing childcare to women has the potential to add $3 trillion to the global economy each year,” she writes.
Expanding child care infrastructure would also create an estimated 43 million jobs globally. McDermott concludes that while working women would benefit most, this shift is ultimately a win-win for everyone.
Designing Your Ideal Retirement with Rajiv Nagaich
Planning for the future is the best way to ensure caregiving responsibilities don’t overwhelm your family. Rajiv Nagaich’s newest program on PBS, Designing Your Ideal Future, is bringing this message to viewers nationwide.
This engaging one-hour special takes you through the principles of creating a retirement plan that supports your values and goals. It is designed to help you turn legal documents into a living system for your future.
The program includes real-world examples and a live Q&A session with Rajiv. It is an essential resource for anyone approaching retirement or those responsible for the future care of a loved one.
Take Control of Your Retirement Journey Today
Rajiv frequently reminds his audience that 70 percent of retirement plans will eventually fail. Many people see their retirement turn into a nightmare of nursing homes and financial exhaustion.
If you want to ensure you don’t become a burden to your family, these resources are your key to success. You can find airtimes by checking your local PBS station’s schedule.
While there, you can learn how to access a free Legal Readiness Quiz and tools to build your LifePlanning system. Don’t sleepwalk into a retirement you never wanted; start planning for a fulfilling future today. And remember – Age on!
The post The Hidden Cost of Caregiving: How Working Women Balance Two Jobs appeared first on Home.
